Direct Indexing for 2020

We found 11 online brokers that are appropriate for Trading Brokers.

Direct Indexing Guide

Direct Indexing

Direct indexing is the next big feature in the financial industry. It is in fact being considered as the future of investing. Throughout this article, we will be discussing direct indexing in detail.

Before we move on to the direct indexing component let us first have a brief look at an index ETF or mutual funds.

These are benchmark components of a market in a bundled product. Let's say there are about 500 major companies in the S&P 500 index and similarly 30 stocks baskets are found in a Dow Jones ETF with respect to price.

Now, an investor who has these funds may gain the same experience and this is the reason we have seen mushrooming of ETFs and index funds in recent years as these are tax-efficient and incurs lower costs.

Furthermore, these ETFs and index funds help in diversification and performance.

Why Direct Indexing

Assume that an investor is an employee of Amazon, which is currently one of the top five companies in the S&P 500. This concept didn't work for Lehman Brothers and Enron employees.

Under direct indexing, one can own S&P 500 but without including the above-mentioned stocks. In other terms, it is a customized index creation.

With direct indexing, a trader can further tailor the choice such as the index of low-cost.

The customization can further go deeper like taking advantage of tax and enhancing returns. A trader can sell the losing positions and take more such steps to gain more.

Direct indexing is the best for those who are retiring as they can sell such holdings which have the least tax impact.

The new financial investing concept helps in avoiding capital gains distributions inherent in ETFs and mutual funds. This is never possible in mutual funds and to some extent in the ETF.

Investors who have low income can harvest some individual stock gains and pay lower taxes.

Direct Indexing Availability

Even though direct indexing seems a new concept it has been in existence for decades in the same way as managed accounts, but then was only available to institutional investors.

Today, with the development of technology it is available to the mass investors.

However, there are some obstacles before direct indexing will reach the masses. Brokerage firms charge commissions of purchase or sale of stocks.

There is one more hurdle. Investors cannot buy fractional shares.

Points to Note

It is well debated whether direct indexing is an active management in disguise. Yes, it can be considered to some extent as the exclusion part offers an experience of investment deviation from the index.

It is also much talked about whether the behavior of an investor would be better or worse. If not, would the behavior be both better and worst simultaneously?

Customization reciprocating better behavior while emotional attachment could result in worse behavior.

Direct indexing is just a click of a button away for including or removing stocks. It is proposed to avoid including and excluding under emotional behaviors.

While discussing a question may arise as to how much cost could be incurred in direct indexing. Frankly, the costs are not clear.

Investors need to pay a bid/ask spread for each buy or sell. Even though the spreads are in pennies, these can keep on adding over time with transactions piling up while excluding or including stocks.

Next comes the tax benefits. The argument hinges on tax alpha but it is important to know that only taxable accounts would be taxed.

This is the reason investors basically chooses nontaxable accounts.

However, it is to understand that tax alpha creation is based on the performance of the overall market. In up market, there is minimum lose while in the down market there is a greater chance of loss.

Direct Indexing and Future

It is undoubtedly said that direct indexing is the future of the investment landscape. Asset management is gradually becoming commoditized and hence the call of show value is becoming stressful among investment managers.

Investment advisors get a chance to know specific wishes, fears, and desires of clients. Then again, they also fear that clients may switch over to other advisors.

Direct Indexing Verdict

Direct indexing is one of the best features in recent years and has both pros as well as cons. It is considered as the foreseeable future of the financial industry.

It is best for investors who believe in customizing the portfolio. Direct indexing offers the benefit of excluding and including stocks as wished or desired.

We discussed above in detail, but it is always suggested to opt for tax benefit and low-cost fees while opting for direct indexing to save more on returns. It is best for individuals in retirement.

We've collected thousands of datapoints and written a guide to help you find the best Direct Indexing for you. We hope this guide helps you find a reputable broker that matches what you need. We list the what we think are the best Brokers below. You can go straight to the broker list here.

Reputable Direct Indexing Checklist

There are a number of important factors to consider when picking an online Brokers trading brokerage.

Our team have listed brokers that match your criteria for you below. All brokerage data has been summarised into a comparison table. Scroll down.

Our brokerage comparison table below allows you to compare the below features for brokers offering Brokers.

We compare these features to make it easier for you to make a more informed choice.

Top 15 Brokers of 2020 compared

Here are the top Brokers.

Compare Brokers min deposits, regulation, headquarters, benefits, funding methods and fees side by side.

All brokers below are Brokers. Learn more about what they offer below.

You can scroll left and right on the comparison table below to see more Brokers that accept Brokers clients

Broker eToro IC Markets XTB FP Markets City Index Trading212 Plus500 Pepperstone EasyMarkets XM FXPrimus
Rating
Regulation Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC), Markets In Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID), Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), Financial Services Authority (FSA), Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), FCA number FRN 522157, Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC), CySEC Licence Number: 169/12, Comisión Nacional del Mercado de Valores, Komisja Nadzoru Finansowego, Belize International Financial Services Commission (IFSC) under license number IFSC/60/413/TS/19, Polish Securities and Exchange Commission (KPWiG) Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), Financial Supervision Commission (FSC) Plus500UK Ltd authorized & regulated by the FCA (#509909), Plus500CY Ltd authorized & regulated by CySEC (#250/14), Plus500AU Pty Ltd (ACN 153301681), ASIC in Australia AFSL #417727, FMA in New Zealand, FSP #486026 and Authorised Financial Services Provider in South Africa FSP #47546 Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), Dubai Financial Services Authority (DFSA), Capital Markets Authority of Kenya (CMA), Pepperstone Markets Limited is incorporated in The Bahamas (number 177174 B), Licensed by the Securities Commission of the Bahamas (SCB) number SIA-F217 Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC), Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) International Financial Services Commission (IFSC), Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC), Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC), Markets In Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID)
Min Deposit 200 200 No minimum deposit 100 25 1 100 200 100 5 100
Funding
  • Bank transfer
  • Credit Card
  • Paypal
  • Bank transfer
  • Credit Card
  • Paypal
  • Bank transfer
  • Credit Card
  • Paypal
  • Bank transfer
  • Credit Card
  • Paypal
  • Bank transfer
  • Credit Card
  • Paypal
  • Bank transfer
  • Credit Card
  • Paypal
  • Bank transfer
  • Credit Card
  • Paypal
  • Bank transfer
  • Credit Card
  • Paypal
  • Bank transfer
  • Credit Card
  • Paypal
  • Bank transfer
  • Credit Card
  • Paypal
  • Bank transfer
  • Credit Card
  • Paypal
Used By 12,000,000+ 60,000+ 250,000+ 10,000+ 14,000+ 14,000,000+ 15,500+ 10,000+ 142,500+ 70,000+ 10,000+
Benefits
  • Offers STP
  • Low min deposit
  • Offers Negative Balance Protection
  • Allows scalping
  • Allows hedging
  • Low min deposit
  • Offers Negative Balance Protection
  • Allows scalping
  • Allows hedging
  • Offers STP
  • Low min deposit
  • Offers Negative Balance Protection
  • Allows scalping
  • Allows hedging
  • Offers STP
  • Low min deposit
  • Offers Negative Balance Protection
  • Allows hedging
  • Offers STP
  • Low min deposit
  • Guaranteed stop loss
  • Offers Negative Balance Protection
  • Allows hedging
  • Offers STP
  • Low min deposit
  • Guaranteed stop loss
  • Offers Negative Balance Protection
  • Low min deposit
  • Offers Negative Balance Protection
  • Allows scalping
  • Allows hedging
  • Offers STP
  • Low min deposit
  • Offers Negative Balance Protection
  • Allows scalping
  • Allows hedging
  • Low min deposit
  • Guaranteed stop loss
  • Offers Negative Balance Protection
  • Allows scalping
  • Allows hedging
  • Low min deposit
  • Offers Negative Balance Protection
  • Allows scalping
  • Allows hedging
  • Offers STP
  • Low min deposit
Accounts
  • Demo account
  • Standard account
  • Islamic account
  • Demo account
  • Mini account
  • Standard account
  • Zero spread account
  • Raw Spread account
  • Islamic account
  • Pro account
  • Demo account
  • Micro account
  • Mini account
  • Standard account
  • Islamic account
  • Demo account
  • Mini account
  • Standard account
  • Zero spread account
  • ECN account
  • Managed account
  • Islamic account
  • Demo account
  • Micro account
  • Mini account
  • Standard account
  • Managed account
  • Demo account
  • Demo account
  • Standard account
  • Islamic account
  • Demo account
  • Mini account
  • Standard account
  • ECN account
  • Islamic account
  • Demo account
  • Micro account
  • Mini account
  • Standard account
  • Islamic account
  • Demo account
  • Micro account
  • Standard account
  • Zero spread account
  • Islamic account
  • Demo account
  • Micro account
  • Mini account
  • Standard account
  • ECN account
  • Managed account
  • Islamic account
Spreads
  • fixed spreads
  • variable spreads
  • fixed spreads
  • variable spreads
  • fixed spreads
  • variable spreads
  • fixed spreads
  • variable spreads
  • fixed spreads
  • variable spreads
  • fixed spreads
  • variable spreads
  • fixed spreads
  • variable spreads
  • fixed spreads
  • variable spreads
  • fixed spreads
  • variable spreads
  • fixed spreads
  • variable spreads
  • fixed spreads
  • variable spreads
Platforms Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps MT4, MT5, Mirror Trader, ZuluTrade, Web Trader, cTrader, Mac MT4, Mirror Trader, Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps MT4, MT5, IRESS, Mac, Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps MT4, Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps MT4, MT5, Mac, ZuluTrade, Web Trader, cTrader, Tablet & Mobile apps MT4, Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps MT4, MT5, Mac, Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps MT4, Mac, Mirror Trader, Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps
Support
  • Live chat
  • Phone support
  • Email support
  • Live chat
  • Phone support
  • Email support
  • Live chat
  • Phone support
  • Email support
  • Live chat
  • Phone support
  • Email support
  • Live chat
  • Phone support
  • Email support
  • Live chat
  • Phone support
  • Email support
  • Live chat
  • Phone support
  • Email support
  • Live chat
  • Phone support
  • Email support
  • Live chat
  • Phone support
  • Email support
  • Live chat
  • Phone support
  • Email support
  • Live chat
  • Phone support
  • Email support
Learn More Sign Up with
etoro
Sign Up with
icmarkets
Sign Up with
xtb
Sign Up with
fpmarkets
Sign Up with
cityindex
Sign Up with
trading212
Sign Up with
plus500
Sign Up with
pepperstone
Sign Up with
easymarkets
Sign Up with
xm
Sign Up with
fxprimus
Risk Warning 71% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. Losses can exceed deposits 82% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money. Losses can exceed deposits 75% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 76% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money. 76.4% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money. CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 79.3% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money Your capital is at risk Your capital is at risk Losses can exceed deposits
Demo eToro
Demo
IC Markets
Demo
XTB
Demo
FP Markets
Demo
City Index
Demo
Trading 212
Demo
Plus500
Demo
Pepperstone
Demo
easyMarkets
Demo
XM
Demo
FXPrimus
Demo
Excluded Countries IR, KP, BE, CA, JP, SY, TR, IL, BY, AL, MD, MK, RS, GN, CD, SD, ZW, ET, GH, TZ, LY, UG, ZM, BW, RW, TN, SO, NA, TG, SL, LR, GM, DJ, CI, PK, BN, TW, WS, NP, SG, VI, TM, TJ, UZ, LK, TT, HT, MM, BT, MH, MV, KZ, GD, FJ, BB, BM, BS, AG, AI, AW, LB, SV, US, PY, HN, GT, PR, NI, VG, AN, AF, GN, SL, BW, IR, SY, MM, IQ, TG, KH, LS, YE, CI , LR, ZW, CU, LY, TZ, CG, ML, BO, LR, NE, AO, GM, NG, AG, GH, KR, KG, GN, SN, NA US, IN, PK, BD, NG , ID, BE US, JP, NZ US, CF, TD, CG, CG, CI, CU, GN, ER, GN, FR, GW, HT, IR, IQ, KR, LB, LR, LY, MM, NZ, NG, SL, SO, SD, SY, TM, UZ, VE, EH, YE, ZW US MY, BE, US, CA, CN, ID, PH, TG, NG, DO, MA, ZW, PR, TZ, TN, UG, BW, AO, AE BR, KR, IR, IQ, SY, JP, US US US, CA, IL, KR, IR, MM, CU, SD, SY AF, CI, CU, IQ, IR, LY, MM, KR, SD, PR, US, AU, SY, DZ, JP, EC.

All Brokers in more detail

You can compare Brokers ratings, min deposits what the the broker offers, funding methods, platforms, spread types, customer support options, regulation and account types side by side.

We also have an indepth Top Brokers for 2020 article further below. You can see it now by clicking here

We have listed top Brokers below.

Direct Indexing List

eToro
(4/5)
Min deposit : 200
eToro was established in 2006 and is used by over 12000000+ traders. 71% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. eToro offers Stocks, Commodities, Forex, CFDs, Social Trading, Indices, Cryptocurrency, Index Based Funds, Exchange Traded Funds (ETF)

Funding methods

Bank transfer Credit Card Paypal

Platforms

Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps

Customer support

Live chat Phone support Email support

Account Types

Micro account Standard account Islamic account VIP account
Regulated by Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC), Markets In Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID), Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC)
IC Markets
(4/5)
Min deposit : 200
IC Markets was established in 2007 and is used by over 60000+ traders. Losses can exceed deposits IC Markets offers Forex, CFDs, Spread Betting, Share dealing, Cryptocurrencies

Funding methods

Bank transfer Credit Card Paypal

Platforms

MT4, MT5, Mirror Trader, ZuluTrade, Web Trader, cTrader, Mac

Customer support

Live chat Phone support Email support

Account Types

Micro account Standard account Islamic account VIP account
Regulated by Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), Financial Services Authority (FSA), Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC)
XTB
(4/5)
Min deposit : 0
XTB was established in 2002 and is used by over 250000+ traders. 82% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money. XTB offers Forex, CFDs, Cryptocurrency

Funding methods

Bank transfer Credit Card Paypal

Platforms

MT4, Mirror Trader, Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps

Customer support

Live chat Phone support Email support

Account Types

Micro account Standard account Islamic account VIP account
Regulated by Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), FCA number FRN 522157, Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC), CySEC Licence Number: 169/12, Comisión Nacional del Mercado de Valores, Komisja Nadzoru Finansowego, Belize International Financial Services Commission (IFSC) under license number IFSC/60/413/TS/19, Polish Securities and Exchange Commission (KPWiG)
FP Markets
(4/5)
Min deposit : 100
FP Markets was established in 2005 and is used by over 10000+ traders. Losses can exceed deposits FP Markets offers Forex, CFDs

Funding methods

Bank transfer Credit Card Paypal

Platforms

MT4, MT5, IRESS, Mac, Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps

Customer support

Live chat Phone support Email support

Account Types

Micro account Standard account Islamic account VIP account
Regulated by Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC)
City Index
(4/5)
Min deposit : 25
City Index was established in 1983 and is used by over 14000+ traders. 75% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider City Index offers Forex, CFDs, Spread Betting

Funding methods

Bank transfer Credit Card Paypal

Platforms

MT4, Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps

Customer support

Live chat Phone support Email support

Account Types

Micro account Standard account Islamic account VIP account
Regulated by Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS)
Trading212
(4/5)
Min deposit : 1
Trading 212 was established in 2006 and is used by over 14000000+ traders. CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 76% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money. Trading 212 offers Stocks, Forex, Commodities, Indices

Funding methods

Bank transfer Credit Card Paypal

Platforms

Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps

Customer support

Live chat Phone support Email support

Account Types

Micro account Standard account Islamic account VIP account
Regulated by Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), Financial Supervision Commission (FSC)
Plus500
(4/5)
Min deposit : 100
Plus500 was established in 2008 and is used by over 15500+ traders. 76.4% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money. Plus500 offers CFDs


Plus500 offer a 100% Free and Unlimited Demo account 0 Commissions Tight Spreads

Funding methods

Bank transfer Credit Card Paypal

Platforms

Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps

Customer support

Live chat Phone support Email support

Account Types

Micro account Standard account Islamic account VIP account
Regulated by Plus500UK Ltd authorized & regulated by the FCA (#509909), Plus500CY Ltd authorized & regulated by CySEC (#250/14), Plus500AU Pty Ltd (ACN 153301681), ASIC in Australia AFSL #417727, FMA in New Zealand, FSP #486026 and Authorised Financial Services Provider in South Africa FSP #47546
Pepperstone
(4/5)
Min deposit : 200
Pepperstone was established in 2010 and is used by over 10000+ traders. CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 79.3% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money Pepperstone offers Forex, CFDs, Social Trading

Funding methods

Bank transfer Credit Card Paypal

Platforms

MT4, MT5, Mac, ZuluTrade, Web Trader, cTrader, Tablet & Mobile apps

Customer support

Live chat Phone support Email support

Account Types

Micro account Standard account Islamic account VIP account
Regulated by Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), Dubai Financial Services Authority (DFSA), Capital Markets Authority of Kenya (CMA), Pepperstone Markets Limited is incorporated in The Bahamas (number 177174 B), Licensed by the Securities Commission of the Bahamas (SCB) number SIA-F217
EasyMarkets
(4/5)
Min deposit : 100
easyMarkets was established in 2001 and is used by over 142500+ traders. Your capital is at risk easyMarkets offers CFD, Forex, Commodities, Indices, Shares, Crypto

Funding methods

Bank transfer Credit Card Paypal

Platforms

MT4, Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps

Customer support

Live chat Phone support Email support

Account Types

Micro account Standard account Islamic account VIP account
Regulated by Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC), Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC)
XM
(4/5)
Min deposit : 5
XM was established in 2009 and is used by over 70000+ traders. Your capital is at risk XM offers Forex, CFDs

Funding methods

Bank transfer Credit Card Paypal

Platforms

MT4, MT5, Mac, Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps

Customer support

Live chat Phone support Email support

Account Types

Micro account Standard account Islamic account VIP account
Regulated by International Financial Services Commission (IFSC), Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC), Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC)
FXPrimus
(4/5)
Min deposit : 100
FXPrimus was established in 2009 and is used by over 10000+ traders. Losses can exceed deposits FXPrimus offers Forex, Social Trading

Funding methods

Bank transfer Credit Card Paypal

Platforms

MT4, Mac, Mirror Trader, Web Trader, Tablet & Mobile apps

Customer support

Live chat Phone support Email support

Account Types

Micro account Standard account Islamic account VIP account
Regulated by Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC), Markets In Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID)